Advisory News Hubb
Advertisement Banner
  • Home
  • Laws & Ethics
  • Financial Advisory
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Laws & Ethics
  • Financial Advisory
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Gourmet News Hubb
No Result
View All Result
Home Laws & Ethics

Timothy B. Dyk: The Education of a Federal Judge

admin by admin
October 16, 2022
in Laws & Ethics


By statute, the Federal Circuit has no more than 12 judges in active service. (Chief Judge Moore, Judges Newman, Lourie, Dyk, Prost, Reyna, Taranto, Chen, Hughes, Stoll, Cunningham, Stark.) The rest are senior. (Judges Mayer, Plager, Clevenger, Schall, Bryson, Linn, Wallach.)

In addition to patent counsel experience, I think it would also be important to have judges with backgrounds in other areas of the court’s jurisdiction (international trade, government contracts, employment law, takings, tax, veterans’ law, etc.)

  1. 2.1.1.2.1

    PatentMom says:

    Thanks for the correction.

    As the Federal Circuit is THE appellate court for patent appeals, I disagree with diluting their expertise with more generalists or people specializing in other areas. I think that is how we got where we are.

    1. 2.1.1.2.1.1

      Dozens says:

      But, look, the same court also has exclusive appellate jurisdiction over international trade disputes, and over government employment disputes, and over Tucker Act cases, and over veterans’ benefit disputes. If “exclusive appellate jurisdiction” means “only pick lawyers related to category X,” then the very charter of the CAFC has set one up for frustration.

      Incidentally, I cannot agree that a lack of patent prosecutors on the CAFC is the cause of our present troubles. At the time that Giles Rich joined the CCPA, he was the first and only patent lawyer on that court. Nevertheless, the patent jurisprudence of that era was excellent. The real source of the rot lies with the SCOTUS, and no amount of changes to the CAFC’s composition will really fix the problem unless and until the SCOTUS problem is solved (ideally by removing the CAFC from certiorari jurisdiction to the SCOTUS).

      1. 2.1.1.2.1.1.1

        PatentMom says:

        I understand that the CCPA sat en banc, so there would always be at least one patent lawyer hearing the appeal. Not necessarily the case with CAFC panels. And Rich was involved in drafting the 1952 Patent Act.

        The CCPA was also less deferential to the USPTO.

        Your point about other duties is well taken. But, most of those are far less complex than patent cases. So, I would still contend that there should be enough patent practitioners on the court to attempt to have one per panel.









      2. 2.1.2

        anon says:

        Trusting Biden’s choice — on anything — reveals how little weight your views should be given, Malcolm.





      3. 1

        Randall+Svihla says:

        Costco is probably not selling this one at a discount.



      4. Patently-O Authors

        Dennis Crouch
        Associate Professor, University of Missouri School of Law
        SSRN Articles
        Jason Rantanen
        Professor, University of Iowa College of Law
        SSRN Articles
        Occasional guest posts by IP practitioners and academics

        Patently-O Tools

        Subscribe to the blog
        About 25,000 individuals now receive Patently-O via e-mail each morning.

        Find a patent job
        We regularly post top patent jobs from leading firms, corporations, and government and educational institutions.

        Submit a patent job
        Find a patent professional among the 15,000+ monthly visitors of the job board, many of whom are patent professionals at large firms and corporations.

        Recent Patent Posts

        Popular Tags

        Categories



      Archives


      A few links

      Contact Us





Source link

Previous Post

How to Plan for Medical Expenses in Retirement

Next Post

Finding The ‘Best’ Financial Advisor Conferences In 2023

Next Post

Finding The ‘Best’ Financial Advisor Conferences In 2023

Recommended

4 Ways to Improve Your Financial Advisor Marketing

5 months ago

SECURE Act 2.0: Later RMDs, 529-To-Roth Rollovers, And Other Tax Planning Opportunities

2 weeks ago

Buyers Guide for your Patent Attorney

2 months ago

How Apple Makes Money

1 month ago

Is Planning A Service Or An Intellectual Property Business?

5 months ago

What Is GDP and Why Is It So Important to Economists and Investors?

4 weeks ago

Advisory-(-White-)

© 2022 Advisory News Hubb All rights reserved.

Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement unless specified. By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • Laws & Ethics
  • Financial Advisory
  • Contact

Newsletter Sign Up.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Laws & Ethics
  • Financial Advisory
  • Contact

© 2022 Advisory News Hubb All rights reserved.